• Latest
  • Trending
Statements about organic farming are not tenable – answer to Ströbel interview

Statements about organic farming are not tenable – answer to Ströbel interview

August 3, 2021
91 Tons per Hectare: Deconstructing the Carrot Yield Record from Tort-Gul

91 Tons per Hectare: Deconstructing the Carrot Yield Record from Tort-Gul

October 16, 2025
Siberian Snowfall Slashes Harvest: A Case Study in Climate Volatility and Agricultural Resilience

Siberian Snowfall Slashes Harvest: A Case Study in Climate Volatility and Agricultural Resilience

October 15, 2025
Beyond the Price Drop: Decoding the September Vegetable Slump and Its Agronomic Implications

Beyond the Price Drop: Decoding the September Vegetable Slump and Its Agronomic Implications

October 14, 2025
A Market Shifts: The Return of Uzbek Pumpkin and its Global Trade Implications

A Market Shifts: The Return of Uzbek Pumpkin and its Global Trade Implications

October 12, 2025
The Pumpkin Profitability Puzzle: Analyzing the Gap Between Cost and Return

The Pumpkin Profitability Puzzle: Analyzing the Gap Between Cost and Return

October 11, 2025
From Commodity to Culinary Destination: The Pumpkimania Blueprint for Agri-Tourism

From Commodity to Culinary Destination: The Pumpkimania Blueprint for Agri-Tourism

October 11, 2025
Beyond the Patch: How a World-Class Pumpkin Festival Builds a Global Agricultural Brand

Beyond the Patch: How a World-Class Pumpkin Festival Builds a Global Agricultural Brand

October 10, 2025
The Blueprint for a Profitable Pick-Your-Own: Analyzing a Premier Pumpkin Event

The Blueprint for a Profitable Pick-Your-Own: Analyzing a Premier Pumpkin Event

October 10, 2025
Reading the Market and the Weather: Keys to a Profitable Pumpkin Season

Reading the Market and the Weather: Keys to a Profitable Pumpkin Season

October 9, 2025
The Festival as a Farm’s Front Porch: Driving Revenue and Brand Loyalty with Agritourism

The Festival as a Farm’s Front Porch: Driving Revenue and Brand Loyalty with Agritourism

October 9, 2025
Outsmarting Pests, Preserving Diversity: A Grower’s Adaptive Strategy Saves the Season

Outsmarting Pests, Preserving Diversity: A Grower’s Adaptive Strategy Saves the Season

October 8, 2025
Sowing Certainty, Reaping Risk: The High Stakes of Seed Integrity and Genetic Purity

Sowing Certainty, Reaping Risk: The High Stakes of Seed Integrity and Genetic Purity

October 8, 2025
  • Company
Thursday, October 16, 2025
Vegetables News
  • NEWS
    91 Tons per Hectare: Deconstructing the Carrot Yield Record from Tort-Gul

    91 Tons per Hectare: Deconstructing the Carrot Yield Record from Tort-Gul

    Siberian Snowfall Slashes Harvest: A Case Study in Climate Volatility and Agricultural Resilience

    Siberian Snowfall Slashes Harvest: A Case Study in Climate Volatility and Agricultural Resilience

    Beyond the Price Drop: Decoding the September Vegetable Slump and Its Agronomic Implications

    Beyond the Price Drop: Decoding the September Vegetable Slump and Its Agronomic Implications

    A Market Shifts: The Return of Uzbek Pumpkin and its Global Trade Implications

    A Market Shifts: The Return of Uzbek Pumpkin and its Global Trade Implications

    The Pumpkin Profitability Puzzle: Analyzing the Gap Between Cost and Return

    The Pumpkin Profitability Puzzle: Analyzing the Gap Between Cost and Return

    From Commodity to Culinary Destination: The Pumpkimania Blueprint for Agri-Tourism

    From Commodity to Culinary Destination: The Pumpkimania Blueprint for Agri-Tourism

    Beyond the Patch: How a World-Class Pumpkin Festival Builds a Global Agricultural Brand

    Beyond the Patch: How a World-Class Pumpkin Festival Builds a Global Agricultural Brand

    The Blueprint for a Profitable Pick-Your-Own: Analyzing a Premier Pumpkin Event

    The Blueprint for a Profitable Pick-Your-Own: Analyzing a Premier Pumpkin Event

    Reading the Market and the Weather: Keys to a Profitable Pumpkin Season

    Reading the Market and the Weather: Keys to a Profitable Pumpkin Season

  • AGROTECHNOLOGY
    • All
    • Climate
    • Crop protection
    • digital (smart)
    • dron
    • Fertilizer
    • Research
    • weed
    Sowing Certainty, Reaping Risk: The High Stakes of Seed Integrity and Genetic Purity

    Sowing Certainty, Reaping Risk: The High Stakes of Seed Integrity and Genetic Purity

    The Double Blow: Analyzing the Systemic Risks Behind a Pumpkin Crop Collapse

    The Double Blow: Analyzing the Systemic Risks Behind a Pumpkin Crop Collapse

    The Water Spinach Specialist: A Blueprint for High-Value Specialty Crops and Cooperative Success

    The Water Spinach Specialist: A Blueprint for High-Value Specialty Crops and Cooperative Success

    Weathering the Storm: How Vietnamese Farmers and Traders Collaborate to Stabilize the Greens Market

    Weathering the Storm: How Vietnamese Farmers and Traders Collaborate to Stabilize the Greens Market

    Stavropol’s Borscht Belt: High-Yield Vegetable Harvest Reaches One-Third Completion

    Stavropol’s Borscht Belt: High-Yield Vegetable Harvest Reaches One-Third Completion

    Yakutia Defies the Odds: Harvest Data Reveals a Surge in Arctic Agriculture

    Yakutia Defies the Odds: Harvest Data Reveals a Surge in Arctic Agriculture

    Beyond the Subsidy: Unlocking True Productivity Gains in Ugandan Agriculture

    Beyond the Subsidy: Unlocking True Productivity Gains in Ugandan Agriculture

    A Double-Edged Sword: Soaring Chinese Cabbage Imports into Zabaykalsky Bring Heightened Biosecurity Risks

    A Double-Edged Sword: Soaring Chinese Cabbage Imports into Zabaykalsky Bring Heightened Biosecurity Risks

    Beyond the Field: How Cooperative-Led Education is Revolutionizing Garlic and Onion Production

    Beyond the Field: How Cooperative-Led Education is Revolutionizing Garlic and Onion Production

  • IRRIGATION
  • SEED PRODUCTION
    • Vegetables
    • Fruit
  • PROCESSING
No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    91 Tons per Hectare: Deconstructing the Carrot Yield Record from Tort-Gul

    91 Tons per Hectare: Deconstructing the Carrot Yield Record from Tort-Gul

    Siberian Snowfall Slashes Harvest: A Case Study in Climate Volatility and Agricultural Resilience

    Siberian Snowfall Slashes Harvest: A Case Study in Climate Volatility and Agricultural Resilience

    Beyond the Price Drop: Decoding the September Vegetable Slump and Its Agronomic Implications

    Beyond the Price Drop: Decoding the September Vegetable Slump and Its Agronomic Implications

    A Market Shifts: The Return of Uzbek Pumpkin and its Global Trade Implications

    A Market Shifts: The Return of Uzbek Pumpkin and its Global Trade Implications

    The Pumpkin Profitability Puzzle: Analyzing the Gap Between Cost and Return

    The Pumpkin Profitability Puzzle: Analyzing the Gap Between Cost and Return

    From Commodity to Culinary Destination: The Pumpkimania Blueprint for Agri-Tourism

    From Commodity to Culinary Destination: The Pumpkimania Blueprint for Agri-Tourism

    Beyond the Patch: How a World-Class Pumpkin Festival Builds a Global Agricultural Brand

    Beyond the Patch: How a World-Class Pumpkin Festival Builds a Global Agricultural Brand

    The Blueprint for a Profitable Pick-Your-Own: Analyzing a Premier Pumpkin Event

    The Blueprint for a Profitable Pick-Your-Own: Analyzing a Premier Pumpkin Event

    Reading the Market and the Weather: Keys to a Profitable Pumpkin Season

    Reading the Market and the Weather: Keys to a Profitable Pumpkin Season

  • AGROTECHNOLOGY
    • All
    • Climate
    • Crop protection
    • digital (smart)
    • dron
    • Fertilizer
    • Research
    • weed
    Sowing Certainty, Reaping Risk: The High Stakes of Seed Integrity and Genetic Purity

    Sowing Certainty, Reaping Risk: The High Stakes of Seed Integrity and Genetic Purity

    The Double Blow: Analyzing the Systemic Risks Behind a Pumpkin Crop Collapse

    The Double Blow: Analyzing the Systemic Risks Behind a Pumpkin Crop Collapse

    The Water Spinach Specialist: A Blueprint for High-Value Specialty Crops and Cooperative Success

    The Water Spinach Specialist: A Blueprint for High-Value Specialty Crops and Cooperative Success

    Weathering the Storm: How Vietnamese Farmers and Traders Collaborate to Stabilize the Greens Market

    Weathering the Storm: How Vietnamese Farmers and Traders Collaborate to Stabilize the Greens Market

    Stavropol’s Borscht Belt: High-Yield Vegetable Harvest Reaches One-Third Completion

    Stavropol’s Borscht Belt: High-Yield Vegetable Harvest Reaches One-Third Completion

    Yakutia Defies the Odds: Harvest Data Reveals a Surge in Arctic Agriculture

    Yakutia Defies the Odds: Harvest Data Reveals a Surge in Arctic Agriculture

    Beyond the Subsidy: Unlocking True Productivity Gains in Ugandan Agriculture

    Beyond the Subsidy: Unlocking True Productivity Gains in Ugandan Agriculture

    A Double-Edged Sword: Soaring Chinese Cabbage Imports into Zabaykalsky Bring Heightened Biosecurity Risks

    A Double-Edged Sword: Soaring Chinese Cabbage Imports into Zabaykalsky Bring Heightened Biosecurity Risks

    Beyond the Field: How Cooperative-Led Education is Revolutionizing Garlic and Onion Production

    Beyond the Field: How Cooperative-Led Education is Revolutionizing Garlic and Onion Production

  • IRRIGATION
  • SEED PRODUCTION
    • Vegetables
    • Fruit
  • PROCESSING
No Result
View All Result
Vegetables News
Home ORGANIC

Statements about organic farming are not tenable – answer to Ströbel interview

by Demin Alexey
August 3, 2021
in ORGANIC
0
Statements about organic farming are not tenable – answer to Ströbel interview
Organic farming should not be underestimated, says Prof. Dr. Jürgen Hess, University of Kassel, and contradicts the statements of an interview on agrarheute a few days ago in a letter to the editor.

Last Monday (July 26th) we had an interview with the agricultural economist Prof. Dr. Herbert Ströbel, former dean of the Department of Agriculture II at the Weihenstephan / Triesdorf University of Applied Sciences (see link below). In an interview, he explained that the concentration on pure organic farming was in his view not very productive and heavily ideologically burdened. At the same time, he criticized university research, which is more geared towards political demands and easier financing than feasible concepts.

We received a letter from Prof. Dr. Jürgen Hess, former head of the organic agriculture and crop production department at the University of Kassel-Witzenhausen. We are publishing this letter here in full and look forward to further discussion on this controversial topic.

Letter to the editor from July 28, 2021 from Prof. Dr. Jürgen Hess

The promotion of organic farming must be linked to its services for the environment and society, demands Prof. Ströbel in an interview published by agrarheute on July 26, 2021. So far, so good, unfortunately the argumentation lacks the depth of focus in the further course, and in part also the factual basis.

Ströbel questions the performance of organic farming and speaks, among other things, of increased nitrate leaching. A current meta-study financed by the Federal Ministry of Agriculture, which evaluated the scientific literature of the past 30 years, shows the opposite. Organic farming does significantly more in terms of groundwater protection, biodiversity, soil fertility and climate adaptation than conventional farming. In relation to the area, this also applies to climate protection, whereby the differences are leveled out when it comes to income.  

The fact that organic farming only delivers 50 percent of the yields compared to conventional farming is simply wrong. All comparisons in this regard are lagging as a result of a poor data basis and a lack of comparability, and they are all the more lagging when the income situation of German intensive agriculture is transferred to the world.

Organic products are no healthier. If you look at the exposure to pesticides, their toxicity hardly plays a role in comparison to the natural toxins that occur in plants anyway. Organic products are sometimes more heavily contaminated with heavy metals and mold.

I am not denying that organic farming can make positive contributions to agriculture in some areas. However, reasonable conventional farming, as practiced by the vast majority of our farmers, is preferable – objectively as well as morally.

It is also not expedient to relate all services to earnings. The appropriate reference value must be decided on a case-by-case basis. To give an example: For water management it is almost irrelevant whether 50 or 90 dt of wheat per hectare are harvested in the water catchment area. Rather, the decisive factor is that the water industry wants little nitrate and no pesticides in the raw water that is extracted. It is not for nothing that the Munich and Leipzig municipal utilities promote organic farming in their water protection area.

At present, organic farming receives about twice as high a subsidy per hectare as conventional. I can only speculate about the motives. Because organic is so popular with the public, it also attracts actors with political or economic considerations, so that organic now also benefits from irrelevant motives .

I argue against offering courses in organic farming because too many options are ignored due to the ideological orientation. The university is committed to science and should not act as a multiplier of ideologies. Sometimes I can understand that universities satisfy the demand for such course content and follow the zeitgeist, but I regret that scientific diligence often falls by the wayside.

Organic farming
Antwort auf Ströbel-Interview: Aussagen zu Ökolandbau so nicht haltbar

/organic/

Tags: cultivationfarmfresh-producemechanical-weed-controlmulchpest
Previous Post

Veterans saluted as John Deere launches Gator XUV Honor Edition

Next Post

The first Ukrainian actinidia plantation

Next Post
The first Ukrainian actinidia plantation

The first Ukrainian actinidia plantation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • Home
  • Privacy Policy
  • Privacy Policy of vegetables.news app

© 2020-2024 VEGETABLES NEWS

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
  • AGROTECHNOLOGY
  • IRRIGATION
  • SEED PRODUCTION
    • Vegetables
    • Fruit
  • PROCESSING

© 2020-2024 VEGETABLES NEWS